Is it cheaper to do your own brakes?

08 Apr.,2024

 

Are you hearing a nasty screech when you press the brake pedal in your car? Does it sound like rock monsters are playing the world’s loudest frame of bowling every time you need to slow down? Well, it may be time to change your brakes. Here’s how.

Learning to Drive Stick-Shift at Mini Manual Driving School

Subtitles

  • Off
  • English

view video

Learning to Drive Stick-Shift at Mini Manual Driving School

This story was originally published on November 5, 2014

How Does A Brake System Work?

A car’s braking system is one of the most important components in your driving experience, as it’s the only thing keeping you from smashing into that bus full of nuns on your spirited run to the grocery store. It’s a fairly simple hydraulic system that allows the force applied at the pedal to be translated to clamping force at the wheel. Here’s how it works:

How Do I Know If I Need To Change My Brakes?

When a brake pad wears down on a rotor, it will often make a squeaking sound when applied. This is an audible safety measure to make sure that the driver knows to change the brakes soon. Unfortunately, some pads don’t do this particularly well, so newer cars have brake pad wear sensors installed as part of their system, alerting the driver on the dash that the pads needs replacement. In addition, when a brake pad gets low, it will require a longer stroke of the caliper’s piston to clamp down on the rotor, therefore lowering the amount of fluid in your brake reservoir. If the pads are low, you’ll be able to see a noticeable change in your brake fluid’s level, and may even get a “BRAKE” warning light on the instrument cluster.

Advertisement

If all these signs are ignored, the pad’s material will wear down to the point where the only thing making contact with the rotor surface is the pad’s metal backing plate, which is made of steel, and it will make heavy grooves in your rotor’s surface, forcing you to replace the rotors as well.

Advertisement

How Much Does It Cost To Change My Brakes?

A typical brake pad job on a regular commuter/non-performance car costs around $50-$80 for all four sets of pads, and about $150-$200 for a set of pads and rotors, front and rear. Labor an an independent shop should be around 1-2 billable hours , so by doing it yourself, you’re saving around $180.

Advertisement

How Do I Change My Brakes?

Note: The procedure listed below was performed on a 2007 Scion tC, but it should be similar in nearly any car with 1 or 2 piston calipers and rotors. If you’re unsure, please consult your car’s factory service manual.

Advertisement

You can perform a brake service on a car with regular hand tools, in your driveway or garage. Here’s how to do it:

Step 1: Acquire Tools

Step 2: Buy Brake Pads And Rotors

With brake pads, ceramic tends to be the best, as they give the best brake feel and the longest protection against brake fade, although dust may accumulate on your wheel a bit more than conventional pads. You can look for pads for your car here.

Advertisement

As far as rotors, unless you’re using the car on a track, any cheap rotor will do, but beware - the rotor manufacturers on some of the cheaper examples don’t have the greatest quality control, and it may be necessary to mill the rotors after you receive them due to vibration when braking. Personally, I’d go for Brembo rotors. They have great quality control and fit/finish for the price. You can also find pad and rotor sets here.

Step 3: Loosen Lugs

In order to get the best purchase on the front lug nuts, engage the parking/emergency brake (if none is available/not working, put a brick behind the back wheel) put your 1/2" breaker bar on the appropriate socket size (usually 17-21mm) and turn counter-clockwise with the car on he ground. Remember, you’re loosening, NOT removing. Get the lugs loose enough that you’ll be able to take them off with a regular ratchet. When working on the rear, put bricks behind the front wheels and engage the parking brake to give yourself the best chance of removing the lug nuts. Release the parking brake when the wheel is off.

Advertisement

Step 4: Raise Car

Put the hydraulic jack underneath either the car’s frame rail or factory jacking points on the side of the car. These can usually be seen as the dimpled pieces of protruding metal on the bottom of the car. Some German cars have black rubber pads that serve as the jacking points.

Advertisement

Place jack stands underneath the car, rest car on jack stands, making sure that its weight cannot shift. You can now remove the wheels. Now is also a great time to clean your wheels of all brake dust. I used a Wagner Steam Cleaner and some Simple Green degreaser:

Advertisement

Step 5: Loosen Caliper

There should be 2 12mm or 14mm bolts on the caliper. Remove them and the caliper should be able to slide out. If te caliper doesn’t slide out easily, use a pry bar or flat head screwdriver and pry it out.

Advertisement

Rest the caliper on the suspension, or use zip-ties or a bungee to secure it to a place where it can’t hang. Don’t put any strain on the brake line.

Advertisement

Step 6: Remove Caliper Carrier

Remove the 2 17mm or 19mm bolts on the rear of the hub that keep the caliper carrier on. These are on tight, so use a breaker bar with a mallet or an impact gun if you can.

Advertisement

Step 7: Remove Rotor

Give the rotor a few good whacks with a hammer and it should come out. Please note that some rotors have a locating screw that would need to be removed for the rotor to come out. Also, on older cars, rust may be an issue, so instead of beating it with a hammer, there may be threaded holes that you can force bolts through and release the caliper that way. You should end up with this:

Advertisement

Step 8: Install New Rotor

Before installing the new rotor, use a wirebrush and take off the rust on the hub, to prevent corrosion in the future. You can also use WD-40 on this part. When installing the rotor, to have it sit flush, use a lug nut and an open-ended wrench to secure it while tightening down the rest of the components. Also use brake cleaner or a degreaser to wipe off the oily packing residue from the rotor.

Advertisement

Step 9: Assemble Carrier

Replace the carrier bolts and tighten them down using an impact gun or breaker bar.

Advertisement

Step 10: Compress Caliper

Using the C-Clamp and one of the old brake pads, compress the caliper piston until the piston is flush with the housing of the caliper. Make sure to have the cap off the brake reservoir, as you don’t want to risk blowing a line.

Advertisement

Step 11: Install Pads and Caliper

Install pads in the carrier and use a little bit of anti-squeal grease on the outside of the pad to ensure smooth operation. Install the caliper bolts and ensure that the caliper moves without binding. Tighten the bolts and double check your work.

Advertisement

Step 12: Put On Wheels.

Tighten the lugs hand tight when in the air, and torque them down when the wheels are on the ground using a torque wrench or breaker bar.

Advertisement

Step 13: Repeat For All 4 Wheels

Step 14: Pump Brakes Until Pressure Is Reached

You should feel pressure within 3 pumps of the pedal.

Step 15: Break In Pads and Braking System

The brakes may squeal or make some noise during the first few miles. This is normal. To break in the new components, on a highway, accelerate to 60 MPH, and gradually slow to 40, and repeat a few times, then 50-30 MPH a few times. Then simply drive normally, and listen for any odd noises. If all is well, you just replaced your brakes. Job done!

Advertisement

Tavarish is the founder of APiDA Online and writes about buying and selling cool cars on the internet. He owns the world’s cheapest Mercedes S-Class, a graffiti-bombed Lexus, and he’s the only Jalopnik author that has never driven a Miata. He also has a real name that he didn’t feel was journalist-y enough so he used a pen name and this was the best he could do.

Thinking about attempting to DIY your next brake pad replacement? While it’s tempting to save a few bucks doing it yourself, an at-home brake pad replacement might not be in your best interest. 

If you’re asking yourself “can I change my own brakes?” then chances are you’ve never done it before — and while replacing brake pads isn’t the hardest job in the world, it is more complicated than it may seem for someone without experience. Before you dive into that DIY brake pad replacement, here are four reasons to think twice before changing your brake pads at home.

1. Replacing Brake Pads Is More Complicated Than It May Seem

There is a whole lot of do-it-yourself auto repair content out there to help you change your own brake pads. But unless you have auto repair experience already, doing things like replacing your own brake pads or even changing your own oil is likely to be more challenging than it seems. 

Not only can a lot of things go wrong if you’re unfamiliar with the parts, but you might be skipping over other significant brake issues without the knowledge on how to diagnose brake problems. What seems like a problem caused by worn brake pads — such as grinding noises or your brake pedal sinking rapidly while you brake — might actually be the result of a damaged rotor or air bubbles in the brake lines. In turn, you may find yourself in need of more complicated repairs or parts than just the pads. 

It's best to avoid changing your brake pads just because they’re a common cause of brake problems. It’s better to have an automotive professional examine your brake system before making assumptions or troubleshooting your brake pads at home. At Firestone Complete Auto Care, we offer a comprehensive brake inspection free of charge.

Pro Tip: For cars with rear drum brakes, changing the brake shoes can be especially complicated due to additional parts and connections the front brakes don’t have. Generally, it’s always best to leave front and rear brake maintenance to a trained service technician.

2. Installing New Brake Pads Requires Expensive Equipment

If you’re not the “fixer-upper” type who performs home and auto repairs regularly, then you may not have all the tools required to change out your car’s brake pads. Typical tools and materials needed for a brake pad replacement include a vehicle jack or lift, jack stands, torque wrench, socket set, caliper compressor, mechanic’s wire and more. If you don’t happen to have these things lying around, that can be a hefty extra purchase before you even begin repairs.

3. Making Mistakes When Changing Brake Pads Can Be Dangerous

Next to seatbelts and airbags, your brakes are among the most important safety mechanisms in your car. Improperly installing new brake pads or putting your brake parts back together incorrectly could compromise the safety of you and your passengers. Being familiar with the parts and repair process is critical to avoiding small mistakes, like a slightly loose caliper fastener that might affect braking performance.

4. Swapping Your Own Brake Pads May Not Be Worth the Time

Consider this: even an expert automotive technician takes between 30 minutes to an hour or more to replace the brake pads and rotors on some vehicles. For someone with little to no experience, brake pad replacement could take several hours or more. 

Learning the process, gathering the right tools, precisely following all the steps, and then putting everything back together again can easily turn into a half-day of work that, ultimately, may not be worth your time.

If you finish the job only to realize that the brake pedal feels off or that your brakes have started making squealing or grinding noises, you may have to start all over to solve the problem and properly install the new brake pads. Talk about a headache! 

Having a professional take care of your brake pad replacement instead is an easy solution that can save you time and money in the long run.

Get Brake Pad Replacement Done Right

You shouldn't have to pay a pretty penny to stop on a dime. Make sure your brake pads are installed safely with a visit to your local Firestone Complete Auto Care. We install brake parts that meet or exceed your manufacturer's specifications, and we guarantee your repair service will be Fixed Right, Priced Right, Right on Time — that's the Firestone Triple Promise. 

Want to save even more money at your next brake service appointment? Download our brake service coupons onto your mobile phone to use at your local Firestone Complete Auto Care repair shop.

Is it cheaper to do your own brakes?

4 Reasons Not to Change Brake Pads at Home